I'm kind of riding on Dionne's coattails here regarding writing rules, but did you know that someone actually came up with a set of written rules for mystery
writing once upon a time? Neither did I.
That is until one day when I accidentally (that's when I find the really cool stuff)
came across them during one of my internet searches. It seems a man named Ronald Knox came up with them in 1929.
Now before you are tempted to dismiss these rules out of hand let me mention that he was
a member of a group of mystery writers called The Detection Club whose membership
included Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, R. Austin Freeman, and
G.K. Chesterton.
Okay here are the Knox's "Ten Commandments” for mystery
writers, with some interpretation from me, because this is my post after all.
Rule Number 1: The
criminal must be mentioned in the early part of the story, but must not be
anyone whose thoughts the reader has been allowed to know.
Explanation: No dropping in a villain on the last page that has not been mentioned in the rest of the whole rest of story please.
Rule Number 2: All supernatural or preternatural agencies
are ruled out as a matter of course.
Explanation: The ghost did not do it.
Rule Number 3: Not more than one secret room or passage is
allowable.
Explanation: This is a mystery not a melodrama.
Rules Number 4: No hitherto undiscovered poisons may be
used, nor any appliance which will need a long scientific explanation at the
end.
Explanation: No making up your own science, that’s cheating!
Rule Number 5: No Chinaman must figure in the story.
Explanation really needed here: This comment was not
meant to be racist. British mystery writers before this time were using often
using foreigners (i.e. Chinaman in a broad term) as the villain just because there were foreigners. After all, no upright Englishman would commit murder. Mr. Knox was objecting to this plot device, not people from China.
Rule Number 6: No
accident must ever help the detective, nor must he ever have an unaccountable
intuition which proves to be right.
Explanation: Detectives do not have "luck" or “hunches”, they have
evidence.
Rule Number 7: The
detective himself must not commit the crime.
Explanation: Would
kind of ruin a series wouldn’t it?
Rule Number 8: The detective is bound to declare any clues
which he may discover.
Explanation: The detective may keep his deductions to
himself, but no secret clues please.
Rule Number 9: The "sidekick" of the detective,
the Watson, must not conceal from the reader any thoughts which pass through
his mind: his intelligence must be slightly, but very slightly, below that of
the average reader.
Explanation: Sidekicks can be silly but not stupid. You have
other characters for that.
Rule Number 10: Twin brothers, and doubles generally, must
not appear unless we have been duly prepared for them.
Explanation: No “Secret Evil Twins” coming out woodwork.
Okay those are the rules. The question is, do mystery writers follow them anymore? Believe it or not I do, and I never even knew there were rules.
Pretty smart fella Mr. Ronald Knox.
Mystery writer C.L. Ragsdale is the author of The Reboot Files a
Christian Mystery Series. A California native, she loves to "surf"
the web to research plot details for her fun, quirky stories with just a bit of
whopper in them. She has a degree in Theatre Arts which greatly influenced her
writing style. Working in various fields as a secretary has allowed her to both
master her writing skills and acquire valuable technical knowledge which she
uses liberally in her plots. She loves to embroider and knit and is a big fan
of the old Scooby Doo cartoons.
Current
E-Books
THE REBOOT FILES: The Mystery of Hurtleberry House, The Island of Living Trees, The Harbinger of Retribution, and The Wrong Ghost.
THE REBOOT FILES: The Mystery of Hurtleberry House, The Island of Living Trees, The Harbinger of Retribution, and The Wrong Ghost.
www.shortmysteriesandtalltales.blogspot.com
http://www.facebook.com/pages/CL-Ragsdale219184744858421
http://www.facebook.com/pages/CL-Ragsdale219184744858421